Home Forums Explore Media Oil Painting The Technical Forum lead pencil lead oil paint do they marry well?

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 47 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #645100
    contumacious
    Default

        Fixing an under drawing prevents the drawing from mixing with your paints, but not from striking through as the paint becomes more transparent.

        My understanding is that the material that makes up the dark line or shape is irrelevant when it comes to strike through (is this the right term to describe underlying layers appearing as top layers become more transparent?) showing up later. The cause is the increased transparency of the layers of paint that allow the darker line or shape to show through. It has nothing to do with the fact that the line was made with graphite or any other material, when it comes to this type of strike through that happens over an extended period of time.

        Charcoal when NOT fixed tends to dissipate as you paint over it, obliterating strong dark lines. It also tends to give less color contamination than graphite. If the charcoal lines are fixed before paint is applied, then the possibility of strike though years later, would be the same as lines made with a graphite pencil or any other tool – if they were of the same strength and contrast against the underlying surface.

        #645068
        Delofasht
        Default

            Ok, lets get it straight….are we talking about mixing with the graphite, or using as an under drawing? I’ve made my case above.

            tidal appears to be looking for a solution to underdrawing that does not involve the usage of an isolation layer. Thus the question regarding how the “lead” of a pencil will interact with oil paint (lead oil paint specifically, but it branches out from there of course). Our answers tend to veer from the main subject here on WC, funnily enough.

            I understand the concern to be honest, as every single additional material used in making a painting will add another level of complexity to the upkeep and understanding of it’s aging. Of course, it is all rather moot if our work is never going to be kept as an heirloom.

            - Delo Delofasht
            #645090
            Dcam
            Default
                #645097
                Ellis Ammons
                Default

                    Ahh Delofasht great minds think alike that is the ones been looking at funnily enough polychromos have emailed company to double check they say they have no wax etc jus oil and lead. Yes ditto I try to keep as simple as possible because the more things you are adding and changing the more suseptible to incompatibility etc as even when you ask commpanys egzactly what is in there product they don’t always tell you everything and even when you do apply the proper rules to using the right thigs together things can still go wrong there are even subtletys within that

                    Polychromos were on sale on amazon last I checked. They used to be 300+ now theyre like 160. I don’t think there is any issue with it. There may actually be some wax in them. I havent had any trouble and I use them frequently. I don’t layer them though. Just a light outline. The binder probably isn’t strong enough to hold down a thick layer of paint. That would be kinda like paiting over pastels.

                    Im using luminance for my next color pencil piece though. I’ve see some work with them and they are out of this world vibrant. Polychromos take much more layering to get a nice saturation. IDK new toys I’m excited about.

                    Check out my work in the acrylics Hall of Fame Camellia WIP
                    oil and acrylic paintings..

                    #645069
                    Delofasht
                    Default

                        Derek, all good! I think your approach is solid, and works quite well. The quality and ability to use various techniques over the isolation coat make it very versatile. I would probably use it more often if I happened to use more detailed underdrawings, but I tend to keep the work more loose and build up all the values after establishing my general color relationships. My approach can vary though depending on the subject matter as well.

                        - Delo Delofasht
                        #645098
                        Ellis Ammons
                        Default

                            More on the polychromos pencil thing.. I used them on Winsor and Newton oil ground and it doesn’t dissolve when you paint a layer over. It’s almost like a dried layer of oil paint. It stays put. Which can be good or bad depending on your needs. You could probably do a underlayer and glaze over it like dcam with no problem. I don’t think you would even need to seal it. It all depends though…

                            Check out my work in the acrylics Hall of Fame Camellia WIP
                            oil and acrylic paintings..

                            #645076
                            AnnieA
                            Default

                                Fixing an under drawing prevents the drawing from mixing with your paints, but not from striking through as the paint becomes more transparent.

                                My understanding is that the material that makes up the dark line or shape is irrelevant when it comes to strike through (is this the right term to describe underlying layers appearing as top layers become more transparent?) showing up later. The cause is the increased transparency of the layers of paint that allow the darker line or shape to show through. It has nothing to do with the fact that the line was made with graphite or any other material, when it comes to this type of strike through that happens over an extended period of time.

                                Charcoal when NOT fixed tends to dissipate as you paint over it, obliterating strong dark lines. It also tends to give less color contamination than graphite. If the charcoal lines are fixed before paint is applied, then the possibility of strike though years later, would be the same as lines made with a graphite pencil or any other tool – if they were of the same strength and contrast against the underlying surface.

                                That last part about charcoal was surprising, but as I think about it, it makes sense if the real issue with strike-thru has to do with the way the paint covering the drawing material experiences increasing transparency over time. And it explains why it’s much less likely to happen with charcoal if it dissipates into the paint. So, the very characteristic that leads me to like The General’s Charcoal pencils – that they’re firmer than regular charcoal and make a more distinct and less smeary line – is likely to lead to strike-through!

                                BTW, Delo, and others who mentioned the OT issue, I don’t really think the issue of strike through can be separated out from the OP’s question. Since there are known problems with graphite strike-through, that’s something to be considered along with any questions about the mixing of the material with the oil paint, and it seemed the right thing to bring it up.

                                [FONT=Arial]C&C always welcome ©[/I] [/font]
                                [FONT=Palatino]
                                “Life is a pure flame and we live by an invisible sun within us.” ― Sir Thomas Browne [/size][/font]

                                http://s3.amazonaws.com/wetcanvas-hdc/Community/images/29-Jul-2007/85002-sig-thumbnail_composite_2.jpg]/img]

                                #645105
                                tidal
                                Default

                                    Annie yes as you say it’s not worth having kittens over..however you wouldn’t want a realy obvious grid on there
                                    Dcam..well it’s a bit of bothe ..using the graphite for an underpainting drawing..which yes argueably some like to put under a layer and redefine a little bit after on the next layer..some like it on there and paint directly over..which is what i was wondering about as charcoal you see is used this way and painted directly over as it will blend wash away etc …and i had read some people did this with graphit/lead pencil albeit a soft one saying it mixed in with the oil paint and there is a coloured lead pencil out there soo..if this clarifies..aparantly the polychromos dont have wax but am double check with company whats in there..yes I can’t abide stretched canvas iether much prefer a sollid wood board but that’s what comes with growing up with a woodworking craftesman lol boy do i know my wood lol
                                    Dcam absoloutly heavenly work there of yours :)

                                    Sculpture is what you bump into when you back up to see a painting..Barnett Newman

                                    #645106
                                    tidal
                                    Default

                                        Oils get more transparent with time especialy linseed and if thin glazes are done then yes under drawing could show through especialy transparent pigments ..so was the thought to use lead coloured pencil polychromos type thing match the undr drawing line colours to final image colours or near to them in tones so instead of grey dark blue etc etc so the show throuhg might add to it rather than takeaway don’t know just a thought for those that like a detailed drawing and the precision a pencil will give ..think they don’t need a fixative

                                        Sculpture is what you bump into when you back up to see a painting..Barnett Newman

                                        #645079
                                        Anonymous

                                            anyone tried it?

                                            yes, absolutely no problem. They even make pure graphite pigment oil paint and it doesn’t migrate or do anything either.
                                            It an under drawing of graphite shows through, for whatever reason, then so would any thing else used for the under drawing. It can happen because of the paint laid over it, probably inadequately.
                                            I did one with very heavy graphite shading, it looks the same as 5 years ago. If the paint ever fades away and becomes transparent, I expect to not be able to care at that point due to my death.

                                            #645091
                                            Dcam
                                            Default
                                                #645080
                                                Anonymous

                                                    sorry Derek, sometimes I don’t even read the previous posts and just comment,
                                                    did you want me to post the painting I am talking about?

                                                    #645081
                                                    Anonymous

                                                        A while ago, I noticed pencil bleed through on an oil painting done in the mid-1800s, so I’ll never use pencil for my underdrawing.

                                                        How did you determine that the pencil was originally not visible at all?

                                                        #645082
                                                        Anonymous

                                                            WC is being a double clutching weasel again. making two posts where there should only be one :lol: .

                                                            #645092
                                                            Dcam
                                                            Default

                                                                Oh: no, I really meant thank you Sid. You were backing up my point.
                                                                My example was for the nay-sayers my friend.

                                                              Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 47 total)
                                                              • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.