Home Forums Art & Vandalism

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #480804
    stlukesguild
    Default

        As artists, most of us likely think of the intentional vandalism of Art as one of the most egregious of offenses. There are dozens of famous acts of Art Vandalism.

        On 10 March 1914, militant suffragette Mary Richardson walked into the National Gallery of London and attacked Diego Velázquez’s painting Rokeby Venus with a meat cleaver.

        Her action was supposedly taken in response to the arrest of fellow suffragette Emmeline Pankhurst. Richardson left seven slashes on the painting, all of which have been successfully repaired. Richardson later stated: “I have tried to destroy the picture of the most beautiful woman in mythological history as a protest against the Government for destroying Mrs. Pankhurst… and the way men visitors gaped at it all day long”. Somehow I doubt her action was a successful method of gaining support for her cause.

        Both Michelangelo’s David and the Pieta have been targets of vandalism, and the Mona Lisa has been targeted several times.

        One of the worst attacks was made upon Rembrandt’s Danaë

        … which was attacked with both acid and a knife. Restoration took over 10 years.

        Rodin’s Thinker, located outside the Cleveland Museum of Art, was targeted in protest of the escalation of the Vietnam War.

        I’m friends with an older artist who claims he knows who the bomber was… but I really don’t want to know more.

        This personal connection brings me to the point of this post. AllisonR (I believe) has spoken of having had one of her paintings vandalized (a male nude, I believe?). It seems that paintings and sculptures of figures… and especially nudes… seem to be the most common targets of vandals. Perhaps
        … on one level… it is power or culture that the figure represents (or is imagined as representing). At the same time, considering how often it is the nude that is the target, you’ve got to wonder whether there is the sexual element behind a lot of vandalism.

        So… beside Allison… is there anyone else who has had their work vandalized? One of my paintings was recently the target of vandalism… and like many of the Art Vandalism cited on Wikipedia and other sites, there was a degree of mental illness behind the attack. One of my studio mates has recently been diagnosed with Parkinson’s. He ignores his doctor’s orders not making frequent visits and refusing to take most of his medication. Unfortunately, one of the symptoms of Parkinson’s is dementia. Over the past month, he has engaged in a personal “war” with our neighbors… including a church headed by the nicest minister. He has repeatedly called the police… and then I found one of my older paintings (c. 2014) vandalized:

        Above is the painting in a photograph from some several years ago. For the last couple of years, it has hung beneath another painting… wholly inaccessible to any vandalism. This past July I moved a number of paintings around and once again this painting (“Temptation”) saw the light of day. In October, I found the work had been vandalized:

        Not only was the painting scrawled on with what appears to have been a pencil, but it was also scratched with what looks like a sharp metal object… like a screw… which tore the paper beneath the lips.

        As a result, I pulled all of my paintings out of the studio and took them home. My other studio mate has already announced that he is leaving… largely because of our partner’s erratic behavior. The other day I spent my time in the studio repairing the painting. The torn area required 4 or 5 layers of acrylic and then sanding, prior to being redrawn. I was concerned that I wouldn’t be able to match the way I had roughly scumbled the flesh-tone pastels over the blues and reds… but luckily, the damage largely avoided these areas. The painting is now restored…

        Now that this painting is out, I plan on making a few changes… or additions… most importantly, a choker around the neck to emphasize the roundness of the neck.

        Unfortunately, this may be one of my few large paintings for a while as I will be looking for a new studio space. Even if I were certain that my studio partner could not damage another painting… and I COULD wall off the space with just an additional 8 or 10 feet of wall and add a door with a lock… I still am facing the fact that my partner’s disease will keep progressing and it is only a matter of time before he can no longer come in and ends up hospitalized.

        Anyway… anybody else ever have your artwork vandalized?

        Saintlukesguild-http://stlukesguild.tumblr.com/
        "Beauty is truth, truth beauty—that is all ye know on earth and all ye need to know." - John Keats
        "Modern art is what happens when painters stop looking at girls and persuade themselves that they have a better idea."- John Ciardi

        #913063
        john
        Default

            Sorry to hear about that SLG. Bummer in multiple ways.

            I suppose that objects of passion incite the greatest passion.

            Sometimes when using scraping techniques on my paintings I feel like I’m vandalizing them. Like how much paper can I remove before there is a hole there. :)

            #913073

            That is appalling that your art was vandalized and I imagine it would be like a punch to the gut.

            No, I have not had any piece vandalized.

            It isn’t just nudes that are vandalized, though. Throughout history there have been many triggers, including ivnasion (vandalism is named for the ‘Vandals’, a Germanic tribe that figured in the destruction of the Roman Empire), suppression of prior rulers’ political statements through art, religious belief, intolerance and bigotry, as well as Puritanism.

            Or just plain mental instability.

            "None are so old as those who have outlived enthusiasm." - Henry David Thoreau

            Moderator Acrylics Forum~~~Reference Image Library

            #913075
            ntl
            Default

                Sorry about that, and glad you got it repaired. Best wishes on speedily finding another studio. Maybe your mate will finally do his meds as he should.

                #913070
                brianvds
                Default

                    At the same time, considering how often it is the nude that is the target, you’ve got to wonder whether there is the sexual element behind a lot of vandalism.[/quote]

                    Probably an element of prudery. I’m sure there are lots of people who fervently wish that all pictures of nudes would disappear, but who don’t quite have the guts to go do it. (And of course, in between ranting and raving about immorality, half of them spend half their time looking up porn on the web).

                    Often, it’s just mental illness; attacking a famous work of art puts you in the same category as shooting Reagan or John Lennon or something like that.

                    Sounds like your studio partner really needs to be institutionalized for his own good. Isn’t there anyone you can call?

                    Lucky for me, my own work is too blandly inoffensive and obscure for anyone to bother vandalizing it. :-)

                    __________________________
                    http://brianvds.blogspot.co.za/

                    #913068
                    La_
                    Default

                        so far it’s been my own clumsiness, foolishness or plain bad luck that’s vandalized/ torn canvas.

                        property, on the other hand, hasn’t been as fortunate … this 7foot ‘beauty’ recently showed up in an empty rental …

                        la

                        _____________________________________________
                        When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know Peace

                        #913071
                        brianvds
                        Default

                            so far it’s been my own clumsiness, foolishness or plain bad luck that’s vandalized/ torn canvas.

                            property, on the other hand, hasn’t been as fortunate … this 7foot ‘beauty’ recently showed up in an empty rental …

                            la

                            So instead of having your art vandalized by people, you have your property vandalized by art. :D

                            But you’re still lucky. At least there’s some attempt there at artistry. A lot of graffiti consists of nothing more than random squiggles. A step up from Twombly perhaps, but still not really the most attractive decoration for a wall.

                            __________________________
                            http://brianvds.blogspot.co.za/

                            #913076
                            ntl
                            Default

                                (Not) funny. Kilz aught to take care of that.
                                Reminds me that I’ve been wanting to do something BIG. MY thought, however, was to use doors that I had replaced, that are now on top of the shed for storage! I don’t recall if they are smooth or ridged.

                                #913066
                                ianuk
                                Default

                                    Sorry to hear of your art being damaged, that must be quite soul destroying.
                                    I’ve been targeted by vandals (not art related) but rarely been affected by vandals, probably because I’ve never had expectations of people to act in any other way than they do.

                                    #913072
                                    Dcam
                                    Default
                                        #913064
                                        stlukesguild
                                        Default

                                            My other studio-mate and I have just reached the point where we can’t deal with him anymore. We both teach art in the inner-city which is stressful enough. We just can’t take coming in on Friday or the weekend intending to get a little work done, and our unstable partner confronts us with the latest drama.

                                            I am sorry for him and I understand that a lot of his behavior is the result of his illness, but I have a family of my own and a stressful job. I can’t deal with his issues. It looks like I’ll be working on a smaller scale until I can find another studio space. Maybe I’ll focus on faces alone for the time being.

                                            Saintlukesguild-http://stlukesguild.tumblr.com/
                                            "Beauty is truth, truth beauty—that is all ye know on earth and all ye need to know." - John Keats
                                            "Modern art is what happens when painters stop looking at girls and persuade themselves that they have a better idea."- John Ciardi

                                            #913069
                                            AllisonR
                                            Default

                                                So instead of having your art vandalized by people, you have your property vandalized by art. :D

                                                Funny.

                                                SLG – glad you could fix your painting so well. I hope you will be able to find good studio space soon, in the meantime perhaps working small will lead you in directions you haven’t even thought of yet. Dementia must be terrible for this man and his family.

                                                In my case it was a male nude, which is somehow less acceptable than a female nude. But mental illness as also involved. It was the homeless that said it would be destroyed, and many of them have underlying mental issues that have not been addressed. If the mental health facilities in this country were better, there would be less people on the streets. Right now if you get a battered leg you get immediate and free health care. If you get a battered brain, you get to wait 18 months and in the meantime pay for private psychologists all on your own, IF you have the money and can actually get an appointment with one.

                                                Being born places you at a greater risk of dying later in life.

                                                http://www.artallison.com/
                                                #913067

                                                Sorry to hear about the vandalism and your studio mate. Glad you were able to fix it though!

                                                The Purple Dog Painting Blog
                                                Find me on Instagram
                                                Find me on Facebook

                                                #913074

                                                Funny.

                                                SLG – glad you could fix your painting so well. I hope you will be able to find good studio space soon, in the meantime perhaps working small will lead you in directions you haven’t even thought of yet. Dementia must be terrible for this man and his family.

                                                In my case it was a male nude, which is somehow less acceptable than a female nude. But mental illness as also involved. It was the homeless that said it would be destroyed, and many of them have underlying mental issues that have not been addressed. If the mental health facilities in this country were better, there would be less people on the streets. Right now if you get a battered leg you get immediate and free health care. If you get a battered brain, you get to wait 18 months and in the meantime pay for private psychologists all on your own, IF you have the money and can actually get an appointment with one.

                                                Allison, I assume you are familiar with the Danish television political drama series Borgen?. There was a storyline on that very issue when the daughter of the principal character (the Danish PM) went through an episode of mental illness and her family placed her in private care, which caused a political scandal.

                                                It is a problem everywhere.

                                                "None are so old as those who have outlived enthusiasm." - Henry David Thoreau

                                                Moderator Acrylics Forum~~~Reference Image Library

                                                #913065
                                                Jon
                                                Default

                                                    I am sorry to hear this, David, for you and for your studio mate.
                                                    I hope this can be resolved for the good of all involved.

                                                  Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
                                                  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.