Home Forums The Learning Center Composition and Design landscape edits – feedback please

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #454566
    artelahe
    Default

        Hi, saw a landscape challenge and did this painting this Rural Countryside. Loved it in the thumbnail but think it could improve with some significant cropping. I will provide the crops following the whole painting
        [ATTACH]856205[/ATTACH].

        [ATTACH]856206[/ATTACH]

        XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

        [ATTACH]856208[/ATTACH]

        Although this is my first cloud and I’m proud of it, I think the focus on the crops works the best of the three.

        -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
        AlyP
        I have a white dog and lots of pastels...but are any of them the right color when I need them to be?

        apagefineart.com[/SIZE]

        #604495

        It’s really a sky painting, so I prefer the last one.

        Doug


        We must leave our mark on this world

        #604499
        artelahe
        Default

            Thank you for the feedback, Yorky. Whilenive been posting these, and while I do lean toward a preference for.panoramic style paintings, I think you are right. It is a sky painting.

            -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
            AlyP
            I have a white dog and lots of pastels...but are any of them the right color when I need them to be?

            apagefineart.com[/SIZE]

            #604496
            La_
            Default

                i like the original
                but also like this option …

                la

                _____________________________________________
                When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know Peace

                #604497
                virgil carter
                Default

                    So…what is your story in this painting? What’s your intent? Not everything in a painting can be of equal importance. Something must be the “star”, and everything else falls into a secondary, supportive role.

                    The more your composition is a 50%-50% ratio, the less clear it is as to what you consider truly important. That’s because you really have two paintings in one here.

                    Sling paint,
                    Virgil

                    Sling paint,
                    Virgil Carter
                    http://www.virgilcarterfineart.com/

                    #604500
                    artelahe
                    Default

                        You are right Virgil. My 2 edits broke it into either a sky or field painting. I was excited about the linear perspective in the corn rows, the rich color, and then found myself lost in the pleasure of seeing the cloud come into being. I gave art birth to fraternal conjoined twins.

                        Thank you for pointing that out. It is best to keep.story and focal point in mind. My thumbnails had it. My cloud stole it. And I lost it.

                        Something to learn from hopefully.

                        La, thank you :)

                        -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                        AlyP
                        I have a white dog and lots of pastels...but are any of them the right color when I need them to be?

                        apagefineart.com[/SIZE]

                        #604498
                        virgil carter
                        Default

                            I understand your design search. I’ve been there. When it comes to these subjects, I’ve come to the conclusion that a portrait orientation may be stronger. That’s because the rule of thirds becomes much stronger and it’s becomes much clearer if the sky or the ground plane is the important story.

                            Here’s an example painting of mine, where the sky is the story:

                            Isn’t watercolor painting wonderful? Always more to explore and learn!

                            Sling paint,
                            Virgil

                            Sling paint,
                            Virgil Carter
                            http://www.virgilcarterfineart.com/

                            #604501
                            artelahe
                            Default

                                Thanks, Virgil. Great sky!

                                -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                AlyP
                                I have a white dog and lots of pastels...but are any of them the right color when I need them to be?

                                apagefineart.com[/SIZE]

                              Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
                              • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.