Home Forums Explore Subjects Plein Air Burnt umber woes

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #463428
    ldavid
    Default

        Is burnt umber a color I should be avoiding (aside from the fact that it “sinks”- do you find it fills your outdoor work?

        #712352
        budigart
        Default

            I use BU all the time, but I’m not an outdoor painter. I paint portraits 90+% of the time. Thus, the BU I use is always part of a mix of colors and generally not the main or only color used. I like it because it tends to promote drying of others colors mixed with it. If I were going to paint a large, dark passage, I would probably mix a dark with other colors rather than using too much BU. Since BU tends to go flat (dry out quickly), some artists oil out their BU passages to keep them from sinking in.

            #712346

            I don’t know any reason to avoid using Burnt Umber. I use it, and Raw Umber in portraits (Vasari paints because of their intensity) and I use them (cheaper brands) in my landscape palette mainly for convenience in getting some of the darks in tree trunks and the like, it’s not a necessity and there are other convenient darks equally useful.

            Mac

            #712349
            chiefswift
            Default

                Good Morning Lisa :wave:

                I do carry the burnt and raw colors into the field BUT find that…

                -naples yellow (sometimes with a bit of cadmium to really make it pop)
                -yellow orche
                -sepia
                -and lastly sometime paynes grey/neautral tint, but more often deep violets and blues

                …make for a more successful painting (in my personal style & opinion) :thumbsup:

                The problem with a color like Burnt Umber is it’s sort of a mid-dark, neutral tone. It requires the brush to be REALLY loaded with paint to stand out. Unless placed to a light or bright color, or “white of the paper,” it’s easily lost value wise. Also, if you place it next to another mid tone or darker wash you risk the whole painting “muddying.” Burnt Umber is also a little granulated making it difficult to life, and even more so to wipe off quickly outside. And though it’s listed as none staining, I find Winsor Newton’s to leave color behind in my experience :smug:

                In my opinion, Burnt Umber is better left for studio work where you have time to plan and avoid those sorts of pitfalls

                Hope that long explanation or my experience with it is of any use. If you want to use the color I would consider confidently painting it in with some real value contrast other than black/greys,

                -Nick

                Edit: Sorry Lisa, I took a look at your website and it appeared you were working with oils :angel: :confused: I think some of the Burnt Umber info is still pertinent, but please disregard any regarding watercolor.

                #712351
                budigart
                Default

                    Nick . . . take another look. Burnt Umber is a dark red.

                    #712350
                    chiefswift
                    Default

                        Nick . . . take another look. Burnt Umber is a dark red.

                        If you take a look at my profile you’ll see I”m red/green colorblind :lol:

                        However I do paint plein air most weekends, and I hope my experience with Burnt Umber based on values (darks & lights), might still be of use :angel: :thumbsup:

                        -Nick

                        #712353
                        budigart
                        Default

                            That’s too bad. But it may help (not sure how) knowing that BU is a very dark red. Old Holland BU makes a great “base” for flesh color. Lay it out in a string, lightening it with white, and you’ll see it begin to mimic ordinary Caucasian flesh tones. By adding a touch of red or orange, you can achieve some rather realistic flesh tones. My basic flesh palette is Old Holland BU, Rembrandt permanent madder deep (sub for aliz crims), yellow ocher and either ivory black or Old Holland Italian Black Roman Earth (used for making neutrals), and RGH cremnitz white.

                            #712354
                            ldavid
                            Default

                                All good advice- I’ve tried mixing it with primaries instead but it’s so convenient!

                                #712345
                                Profi9le
                                Default

                                    I’m liking raw umber these days for plein air landscape painting. It greys down the colors I mix with my split-primary palette nicely. Great for dulling down a blue sky that is too intense.

                                    Michael Chesley Johnson AIS MPAC PSA
                                    www.MChesleyJohnson.com

                                    #712356
                                    TomMather
                                    Default

                                        I love burnt umber and use it more than any color except ultramarine blue and titanium white. However, I mainly use it for mixing. It makes a nice grey mixed with ultramarine and white. It makes a near black mixed with ultramarine. Add a little yellow, and it makes a very dark green. I often use it to sketch in the composition on a new canvas. It’s a great color for mixing grays in rocks, tree trunks, sand and oil. As others mentioned, it also speeds drying.

                                        As far as sinking in goes, it is more prone than many colors. However, you can alleviate that by adding more medium when mixing colors, or by oiling out after the painting dries.

                                        #712355
                                        Bartc
                                        Default

                                            I am a plein air painter, but I don’t use oils, rather acrylics, watercolors, Ceracolors, etc. In those media BU is highly useful for darkening yellow range colors. You cannot use black for that purpose as black is usually really a blue, so it comes out greenish. But for yellows that BU is a perfect way to create darker shades. In watercolors it helps to mix dark shades toward black, since already mixed black is superfluous in WC.

                                            On its own I try not to use it. In acrylics I’m finding that it tends to flatten the painting in a way that I don’t particularly like. Because I’m not using oils, how it impacts drying is beyond me.

                                            #712347
                                            vhere
                                            Default

                                                BU is great for greying down blues and in other mixes as is raw umber. I use it in oils, acrylics and watercolours (along with a lot of transparent colours).

                                                I like Griffin Alkyd quick drying oils – all colours dry at the same rate

                                                #712357
                                                Ted B.
                                                Default

                                                    I’ve read that before WW1 some of the Roman academies turned their students loose on the city with only Burnt Umber and Flake White. It was very inexpensive paint (starving artists…) and they could concentrate on tone, composition and technique without the distraction of “color”. And BU is typically very fast drying.

                                                    So many outdoor paintings ultimately “fail” due to poor mastery of value and too-much chroma.

                                                    Radical Fundemunsellist

                                                    #712358
                                                    DK4242
                                                    Default

                                                        Burnt umber is good for making black and dropping chroma. A little bit goes a long ways.

                                                        #712348
                                                        skipstah
                                                        Default

                                                            You might want to avoid applying it in thick mixtures over other paint, but it is one of the best colours to use for underpainting or early thin stages IMO.

                                                            WEBSITE

                                                          Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
                                                          • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.